Strategies to make student talk collaborative and productive corwin literacy 9781544382180. Brisbin, matthew, using studentled discussion strategies to motivate, increase thinking, create ownership, and teach citizenship 2015. Browse the amazon editors picks for the best books of 2019, featuring our. Classroom discussion shouldnt always be teacher led. We published a version of this manual intalking studentslistening teachers. Your efforts may succeed wonderfully or lead to tense and awkward moments. By creating roles within each literature circle or book club group and specific tasks for the group to accomplish during their text discussion time, teachers can modify the work to make it more studentcentered. It presents a series of cases of students facilitation strategies and using qualitative data analysis of discussion threads within the naturalistic inquiry framework. Studentled conversations in book clubs inspire me asap. How do i promote rich conversations about books, videos, and other media. Teachers have to use strategies that help students learn how to attend to each others ideas and the mathematics. This book details a framework for implementing studentled classroom discussions that improve student learning, motivation, and engagement across all levels. Check out these 10 techniques for classroom discussion that put the students in charge of the talks. Students then use the strategy to develop questions for a peer led book discussion.
Afterward, she enthusiastically shared what she had learned about facilitating effective student led discussions. There was only time for each student to ask one question, and followup questions developed to take the place of the prewritten ones. Instructordesigned questions help instructor to guide pre discussion reading and preparation distribute questions on the course schedule or on a learning management system such as canvas. Strategies to make student talk collaborative and productive.
Tell students that, in this session, they will be choosing the books they will discuss in their book club. With middle school students, the booktalk can be an effective tool to hook reluctant readers and is an important component of independent reading time andor a readers workshop. What do students talk about in peer led discussion groups when they are asked to make meaning of a literary text. Implementing literature discussion groups in classrooms enhanced. Youll need to get the class involved and attempt to create a dynamic discussion.
During discussion when the conversation slows down, pull one of the slips out to keep the conversation going. In each strategy, students select books they wish to read with a group of their peers. Opinion texts writing task movies are more enjoyable than books. The resulting text related discussions between students in the peer led discussions were more elaborate than the discussions that were teacher led. Student led discussion strategies are a great way to boost collaboration in your classroom. Dabbagh and kitsantas personal learning environments, social media, and selfregulated learning.
Students have more opportunities to use language to learn language. There are several ways you can lead class discussion. How to tackle studentled discussions ascd inservice. Classroom discussions are a perfect place to develop students ability to use textual evidence. How do studentled discussions align with established standards. Decide on the number of student led book discussions you will have each week. And for more ways to get students creating and reflecting on a regular basis, check out these blogging alternatives. Goals of the day identify action steps to begin or improve student led discussions focus on discussion strategies, instructional practices, and deeper thinking students need to. Literature circles and book clubs betterlesson coaching. If youve got lessons plans, videos, activities, or other ideas youd like to contribute, wed love to hear from you.
In this strategy three to five students stand in a small inner circle. Last week, i wrote about accountability with book clubs, which you can read more about here. When his class needs a motivational boost, one of the ways mr. Let the discussion peak by asking questions that require students to apply concepts and principles they have developed to new data and different situations. Ultimately, textual evidence is what makes students answers credible.
They prepare for a group meeting by reading agreedupon pages, with the followup discussion led members of the group. Studentled discussions can be an authentic, lowstakes, and fun way for students to talk to one another about academic concepts. How to hold a better class discussion the chronicle of higher. Instructordesigned questions help instructor to guide prediscussion reading and preparation distribute questions on the course schedule or on a learning management system such as canvas. It involves selecting and interpreting just the right evidence, says john riley, the great books foundations director of professional learning. Model the discussion facilitation strategies you want your students to employ. In addition to providing a discussion framework that requires students to think deeply and communicate effectively, she includes advice for how to. More often, though, they discuss reading materials at their independent levels, in literature circles and book clubs. Until then i had been running discussions in the familiar way. Create a free teach starter account and download hundreds of timesaving resources. It helps gives students three crucial ingredients for student led learning purpose, audience and real stakes. Oct 16, 2014 these teacher and experttested strategies will strengthen your students ability to find and use evidence from any text. Tell students the reading and writing choices they will have after they complete a discussion and journal work. Introduce the books that you have chosen by giving a brief summary of each and sharing some of the main themes.
Student led discussions effective classroom participation sunday, august 21, 2016. Sep 28, 2016 student seminar leaders have to lead discussion for the first 30 minutes, then do the database tour, then we break, and then i take over. Toward the end of the year student led seminar time expanded from 30 minutes to a full hour as students got more confident, which was awesome to see. This is 2nd grade class studentled discussion by authentic education on vimeo, the home for high quality videos and the people who love them.
Effects of literature discussion groups on reading. This is a discussion strategy that asks students to practice argumentation, whether it be use of rhetorical appeals and techniques, recognition of a counterclaim, or avoidance of logical fallacies. Socratic seminars allow students to develop inquiry skills in the context of collegial discussions. For ells, academic discussions are critical to language and content development because. Invite them to discuss a story or several chapters in a book. Blogging has become increasingly popular in classrooms, for good reason. In my class, unprepared students read the pages in class before joining their group.
Qar is an explicit and straightforward strategy that helps students identify questions as in the book or in my head. I organized the discussion into four rounds of seven minutes. Drexler,the networked student model for construction of personal learning environments. Before this school year started, as i was thinking of what i might focus on for a blog series, i kept coming back to the idea of classroom discussion. The instructor is available to answer questions and guide the discussion if necessary, but the emphasis is on the exchange of student ideas to help students see a variety of views on a given topic. See more ideas about teaching, teaching reading and reading workshop. Studentled facilitation strategies in online discussions. A framework for cultivating student led discussions use conversation to raise student learning. In studentled discussions, author sandi novak offers you the resources you need to develop meaningful studentled conversations about text and media across the content areas. As such, it is inevitable that some students will be more intellectually engaged and will speak more than others. Apr 24, 2018 in a student led discussion, teachers generally divide the class in two, which in an averagesize classroom results in 10 to 15 students per group. Guidebook for student centered classroom discussions page 3 1b a contrast of student centered and faculty led discussion learning is an interactive process between the student, the teacher, and the subject matter. They start with students arriving to class having read a shared text.
Students are introduced to the questionanswer relationship qar strategy through a readaloud and question sort. Today, i am writing specifically about studentled conversations in book clubs. Give students about 20 minutes to browse through the books and make a list of their top three choices. Sandi novak is an education consultant and author of the ascd arias studentled discussions. Each of the four segments of the facilitating studentled discussions series provides a 30minute standalone session appropriate for k12 professional development in all subjectscontents during faculty meetings, before or after school, or during teacher planning time. Socratic seminar bingo by building book love instructional strategies. Ela teaching strategies for small group discussions. Discussion strategies and activities for student engagement. Guidebook for studentcentered classroom discussions. One or two studentled discussions occur within the school year. Time allocation grades 312 each studentled discussion cycle takes about one to three weeks.
One or two student led discussions occur within the school year. Literature circles and book clubs are a text discussion strategies that supports studentled facilitation and discussion in small groups. Lets first identify some characteristics of student led conversations with book clubs. This study explored student led facilitation strategies used to overcome the challenges of instructordominated facilitation, enhance the sense of learning community, and encourage student participation in online discussions. She has more than 30 years of experience as an assistant superintendent, principal, curriculum and professional learning director, and teacher. Why are academic discussions so important for our ells. This conference model effectively positions students as experts in their own learning, and highlights their voices and insights to drive a rich discussion. Whereas the other formats in this list have a distinct shapespecific activities you do with students the strategies in this section are more like plugins, working discussion into other instructional activities and improving the quality and reach of existing conversations.
Teacher practices that impact reading motivation reading. These elements and strategies appear to be important. Student led discussions effective classroom participation. Each of you will have an opportunity to work in pairs and lead class discussion for 30 minutes. Do you struggle with student led discussion strategies. Student led discussion strategies for whole class discussion. This product is my way of generating an authentic student led discussion. A teachers guide to building studentled discussions posted october 22, 2015 in classroom management, teaching strategies for college and career success in the 21 st century, teachers must develop students speaking, listening, collaboration, and independentthinking skills. Teaching strategies for a successful classroom discussion.
What core elements are needed for students to engage in rich discussions. Strategies for student centered discussion high school. A framework for cultivating student led discussionsuse conversation to raise student learning, motivation, and engagement in k12 classrooms. Student led discussion groups these types of small groups are led by a student and meant to stimulate discussion on a given topic. I teach 5th grade and i could see using some of these strategies with the students in my classroom. Chunk books by having students read three to four chapters, then stop to hold a partner or small group student led discussion on that section. Model this strategy for students so they can understand their role and become comfortable in the classroom discussion. This sampling of strategies provide ideas for helping students prepare for discussions and for collaborating with others to develop those ideas.
To show everyone what a meaningful discussion looks like, place a group of four or five students on center stage in front of the room. This study explored student led facilitation strategies used to overcome the. Prize in american studies for his 2004 book emancipating pragmatism. Whole class discussions are, after lecture, the second most frequently used teaching strategy, one mandated by the common core state standards because of its many rewards.
Why are academic discussions so important for ell students. Four steps to deepen student discussions about math. Amount of time for students to discuss ranges from ten to thirty minutes. Promoting engagement through student led discussions k12 march 1, 2017. This is my sixth post in my eight post series about implementing book clubs into your classroom. These benefits, however, do not manifest without a skillful and knowledgeable facilitator. Guidebook for studentcentered classroom discussions page 3 1b a contrast of studentcentered and faculty led discussion learning is an interactive process between the student, the teacher, and the subject matter.
A powerful form of thinking and communicating, student led conversations can last from five to 15 minutes and bring social interactions to students learning. Gale rhodes contact information robert schaible, professor of arts and humanities, lewistonauburn college. Not all mathematical discussions have the same aim or should be led in the same way. Facilitating studentled discussions instructional moves. Students have authentic conversations and is not rolebased as i mentioned in my first blog post, i moved away from assigning roles, such as super summarizer or cool connector because it limited my students. Instructional adaptations are made for individual children 9 amounts of instruction 9 intensity of instruction 9 practice on the five component.
The following strategies can help you intentionally incorporate discussion strategies and accountable talk into your daily instruction in a way that will help students remain engaged. Student led facilitation strategies in online discussions. The number will change and depend on other reading experiences that you offer students. After years of experimentation with studentled discussions, ive honed. Here are a few of quick and easy discussion strategies that keep our students engaged. A framework for cultivating student led discussions use conversation to raise student learning, motivation, and engagement in k12 classrooms sandi novak, cara slattery on. Emerson likes to reengage his students is by turning the tables on them. Switching up discussion leadership keeps students on their toes and protects class from growing predictable or stale. Throughout my teaching career, i have used booktalks on a regular basis to motivate, inspire, and share quality literature with students.
A teachers guide to building studentled discussions. Sometimes i feel like i am so focused on getting everything accomplished that i leave out the important things like the student centered discussions. Heres how it works as far as with classroom discussions. Students develop academic selfcompetence i got this. In addition to providing a discussion framework that requires students to think deeply and communicate effectively, the includes advice for how to introduce and cultivate student led discussions about literary and informational material at any grade.
Studentled discussions develop 21stcentury learning skills. I use these discussions in my class to gauge my students learning as an alternative to a reading quiz. Facilitating studentled discussions according to tim mccarthy, provoking discussion gives students a powerful opportunity to flourish. Literature circles and studentled book clubs are both instructional strategies that allow students choice, voice and motivation in reading. Amount of time for students to discuss ranges from two to fifteen minutes. Baran and correia, studentled facilitation strategies in. Ells need the opportunity to hear language in authentic and varied contexts. There are many ways to set up this engaging group discussion strategy and adapt it to your classroom or setting. Studentled discussion groups appropriate student level. Among such resources are links to authentic video clips of students engaged in discussions. How to use math talk cardsposters to promote studentled. For the discussion, students create their own questions and respond to their classmates over the most recent work of liter.
After the children learned the norms of wholegroup literature discussions, they began smallgroup discussions about a book they had all read. The big list of class discussion strategies cult of pedagogy. How much of their time is spent in use of comprehension strategies and what kind of comprehension strategies do they use. What classroom structures are needed for studentled discussions. Mar 18, 2016 my school has fully incorporated the student led conference model over the past few years. For example, round one was chapter seven, so students who wrote questions for that chapter jumped into the fishbowl.
Whereas the other formats in this list have a distinct shapespecific activities you do with studentsthe strategies in this section are more like plugins, working discussion into other instructional activities and improving the quality and reach of existing conversations. I recommend starting by implementing student led literary discussions. As a quick reference to support a practice you learned in a pd workshop or book. Once students are warmed up, ask questions requiring students to explain relationships among the units of information and to form general concepts. Time allocation grades 312 each student led discussion cycle takes about one to three weeks. Stories that are driven by character actions and motivation are the ones that inspire discussion. Discussion strategies and accountable talk in the classroom. What books are you reading to your students this w. Students take turns assuming the role of teacher in order to guide the groups discussion in an organized and comprehensive manner. Designing effective discussion questions teaching commons.
Mar 06, 2018 after years of experimentation with studentled discussions, ive honed three approaches that have made almost all conversations in my classroom both complex and enlightening. Decide on the number of studentled book discussions you will have each week. How do i get started as a 1st3rd grade teacher what do studentled discussions look like in grades 4 and 5. When you want to help your students learn a specific strategy, routine, or approach, but arent sure how to do it.
This strategy can be used separately or in combination with the question slips above. Common core facilitating studentled discussions georgia. Use leveled books in student led discussions middleweb. Student led conferences, admittedly, take more time to prepare than traditional conferences. Students started to see the value in wholegroup discussions as the discussions became a forum for sharing and recommending books. Reading rockets is a national multimedia project that offers a wealth of researchbased reading strategies, lessons, and activities. So i read good books and share them, and i listen to kids tell me about them. According to tim mccarthy, provoking discussion gives students a powerful opportunity to flourish. Studentled discussion handout for any novel or article tpt. Consider the consequences of being unprepared for a book discussion. Get timesaving teaching tips, effective strategies, and awesome freebies right to your inbox. Using studentled discussion strategies to motivate, increase. Williams students sat in a circle, holding their books and graphic organizers filled with notes.
Academic discussions help all students develop reasoning skills and deepens understanding of content and multiple perspectives. A natural formula for connecting formal and informal learning viii. However, just because students may have participated in discussions their entire academic lives, they may not have considered discussion facilitation pedagogically. The jigsaw teaching strategy is a cooperative learning technique that forces students to complete an individual task so they can share their knowledge within a group. Promoting engagement through studentled discussions k12. Strategies for impact on student lrning by laura gilchrist this newsletter was created with smore, an online tool for creating beautiful newsletters for educators, nonprofits, businesses and more. Notice and note, book clubs, and socratic seminar wednesday, january 29, 2020 at i. His most recent book is discussion in the college classroom. Eventbrite middle school quality initiative presents student led discussion. Reciprocal teaching is a student led discussion strategy where students in small groups are assigned roles related to a comprehension strategy i. Each category of questions has two subdivisions as follows. It also provides a common language for teachers and students to discuss texts. The onyourfeet guide to studentled discussions corwin.
Everything students do at school should equip them for developing collaboration, communication, critical thinking, and creativity. Teaching in a harkness school more than ten years ago led me to. Students sitting in a circle, discussing their reading assignment. Give students the language they need to ask a question or reply with a comment or relevant thought during a discussion. Lets first identify some characteristics of studentled conversations with book clubs. How to build meaningful student led discussion pack meaningful student led discussion stems. These are some great ideas that can be implemented in the classroom to help student led discussions. Oct 09, 2017 literature circles and student led book clubs are both instructional strategies that allow students choice, voice and motivation in reading. Teaching your students productive ways to discuss their thoughts and ideas with their peers is an incredibly powerful tool. Find out how he puts them in charge of the lesson, so they can teach each other, while he sits back to enjoys the show.
1004 107 1460 924 978 280 925 1182 1343 1242 1551 643 1030 25 146 931 1124 1030 583 744 690 1322 145 678 1276 797 1489 1423 294 33 1464 405 110